Papaya Global vs MyPAYE Online Payroll: UK Reviews & Prices Compared (2025)

We compare them based on real user reviews, prices and what features they both offer.

Papaya Global vs MyPAYE Online Payroll Basics

	Papaya Global	MyPAYE Online Payroll
Software Website	Papaya Global Website	MyPAYE Online Payroll Website
Company Name	papayaglobal	My PAYE Ltd
Target Company Size (Small, Medium and/or Enterprise)	Enterprise	Medium
Industry Focus	None	None

Wondering if Papaya Global or MyPAYE Online Payroll has better user reviews. We compared them below.

	Papaya Global	MyPAYE Online Payroll
Listed On HMRC Website	No	Yes
Trustpilot Rating	2.6	2.9
Number of Trustpilot Reviews	6	3
iPhone App Rating	No Rating	No iPhone App
Number of iPhone Reviews	No Reviews	No Reviews
Android App Rating	No Rating	No Android App
Number of Android Reviews	No Reviews	No Reviews

Please note ratings we’re accurate at the time of writing but may have since changed

Which is cheaper Papaya Global or MyPAYE Online Payroll? Here are their prices compared.

	Papaya Global	MyPAYE Online Payroll
Listed As Having Free Plan By HMRC?	No	No
Free Plan?	No	No
Free Trial?	No	Yes
Free Trial Length?	Not Applicable	30 days

Data taken from each company’s website at the time of writing but may have since changed.

Data taken from each company’s website at the time of writing but may have since changed.

Upgrade your payroll and payments technology without replacing your payroll partners
No need to rip and replace your existing payroll network
Quickest â€œGo Liveâ€ on the market

Calculation of PAYE
Calculation of Employeeâ€™s NIC
Calculation of Advance (Holiday) Pay
Calculation of Pension Contributions
Calculation of Student Loan Repayments
Calculation of Earnings Attachments
Calculation of Statutory Sick Pay
Calculation of Statutory Maternity, Paternity, Adoption and Shared Parental Pay
Printing of payslips with support for security payslip formats and optional email delivery of payslips
Printing of pay summaries for each payroll run
Printing of Accounts (Nominal Ledger) Reports for each payroll run
Calculation and printing of Statutory Return information for monthly/quarterly HMRC payments
Export of Pay Summaries, Nominal Ledger, Statutory Return and Pay Analysis to Excel via csv file
Ability to reprint Payslips and other reports for current Tax Year and at least 3 previous Tax Years
Printing of P45 forms for leavers
On-line submission of HMRC RTI Full Payment Details, Employer Payment Summary, Employer Alignment, Earlier Year Update and National Insurance Number Verification
Automatic retrieval of Payroll Notices (Tax Coding Notices, Student Loan Notices, Notification Notices etc.) from HMRC
Support for Weekly, Fortnightly, 4-Weekly, Monthly, Quarterly and Annual payroll cycles
Invoices sent by email and viewable on-line
Provision of On-line help plus Technical Support via built-in support centre
Generation of HMRC Generic Payroll file for payroll audit
Generation of copies of HMRC Submission files and HMRC Acceptance messages for payroll audit

	Papaya Global	MyPAYE Online Payroll
Unlimited Payrolls	No	No
Automated Tax Filing and Payments	Yes	No
Live Customer Support	No	No
Ability To Manage Employee Benefits	Yes	Yes
Employee Access To Platform	Yes	No
Direct Deposit	Yes	No
Expense Reimbursement	Yes	Yes
Time Off Tracking	Yes	Yes
Handle Deductions From Pay	No	Yes
Debt Repayment From Pay	No	Yes
Employee Background Checks	No	No
Has An API	Yes	Yes
Create Payslip	No	Yes
Create P45	No	Yes
Create P60	No	No
Pay For Salaried Employees	Yes	Yes
Pay For Hourly Employees	Yes	Yes
Bonus / Incentive Pay	No	No
Pension Filing	No	Yes
Statutory Payments (E.g. Sick Pay, Maternity Pay, etc.)	No	Yes
Direct HMRC Submissions	No	Yes
RTI Compliant	No	Yes