Which payroll software is better BrightPay or TaxShield P11D Manager?
We compare them based on real user reviews, prices and what features they both offer.
 |  |
BrightPay vs TaxShield P11D Manager Basics
BrightPay | TaxShield P11D Manager | |
| Software Website | BrightPay Website | TaxShield P11D Manager Website |
| Company Name | BrightPay | Taxshield |
| Target Company Size (Small, Medium and/or Enterprise) | Medium | Medium |
| Industry Focus | None | None |
BrightPay vs TaxShield P11D Manager Reviews
Wondering if BrightPay or TaxShield P11D Manager has better user reviews. We compared them below.
| BrightPay | TaxShield P11D Manager | |
| Listed On HMRC Website | Yes | Yes |
| Trustpilot Rating | 4.6 | No Rating |
| Number of Trustpilot Reviews | 188 | No Reviews |
| iPhone App Rating | 2.8 | No iPhone App |
| Number of iPhone Reviews | 49 | No Reviews |
| Android App Rating | 3.3 | No Android App |
| Number of Android Reviews | 173 | No Reviews |
BrightPay vs TaxShield P11D Manager Prices
Which is cheaper BrightPay or TaxShield P11D Manager? Here are their prices compared.
 |  |
Free Plans & Trials
| BrightPay | TaxShield P11D Manager | |
| Listed As Having Free Plan By HMRC? | No | No |
| Free Plan? | No | No |
| Free Trial? | Yes | Yes |
| Free Trial Length? | 60 days | Not Specified |
Paid Plan Prices
| BrightPay | TaxShield P11D Manager | |
| Cheapest Plan Cost Per Month | £79.00 | Pricing Not On Website |
| Mid-Tier Plan Cost Per Month | £289.00 | NA |
| Top Plan Cost Per Month | £689.00 | NA |
BrightPay vs TaxShield P11D Manager Features
 | |
BrightPay Basic Features
- One employer
- Up to 3 employees
- Full functionality and free support.
BrightPay Software Integrations
- Exact
- Kashflow
- Sage
- Quickbooks
- Xero
TaxShield P11D Manager Basic Features
- P11D, P11D(b) and P46 car HMRC-approved forms
- Market leading security
- Easy import of your existing data
- File By Internet (FBI) facility for P11D and P46 car forms
- No installation required
- Access your data anywhere
- Automated P46 car creation, for those companies where changing vehicles is a time consuming role
- Mac compatibility
- Co2 car list, so that you can select from industry-wide car makes and models
TaxShield P11D Manager Software Integrations
Not Listed
Common Feature Comparison
| BrightPay | TaxShield P11D Manager | |
| Unlimited Payrolls | No | No |
| Automated Tax Filing and Payments | No | No |
| Live Customer Support | No | No |
| Ability To Manage Employee Benefits | Yes | Yes |
| Employee Access To Platform | No | No |
| Direct Deposit | No | No |
| Expense Reimbursement | No | Yes |
| Time Off Tracking | No | No |
| Handle Deductions From Pay | Yes | No |
| Debt Repayment From Pay | No | No |
| Employee Background Checks | No | No |
| Has An API | Yes | No |
| Create Payslip | Yes | No |
| Create P45 | Yes | No |
| Create P60 | Yes | No |
| Pay For Salaried Employees | Yes | Yes |
| Pay For Hourly Employees | Yes | Yes |
| Bonus / Incentive Pay | No | No |
| Pension Filing | Yes | No |
| Statutory Payments (E.g. Sick Pay, Maternity Pay, etc.) | Yes | No |
| Direct HMRC Submissions | Yes | Yes |
| RTI Compliant | Yes | No |
More Comparisons
BrightPay vs Technology One Human Resource and Payroll
BrightPay vs TRG Advantage Payroll
BrightPay vs Unit4 Payroll
BrightPay vs WCBS HR & Payroll
BrightPay vs Wealden HR Pay